Global Development Institute Blog

Global Development Institute Blog

We’re the Global Development Institute at The University of Manchester: where critical thinking meets social justice.

Solidarity in times of the ‘refugee crisis’: the emergence of a politics of resistance?

By Tanja R. Müller

Even as – at least when listening to the media – it seems that Europe faces a unique challenge with the increasing numbers of refugees (or as the British media prefers to call them, towing the government line, migrants), who flee war in Syria and destitution in other places, it is pertinent to remember that people have fled persecution and hopelessness since times memorial. But each contemporary ‘crisis’ presents itself these days as something quite extraordinary, something that has not happened before. Not so long ago, it was Israel’s turn to ‘discover’ its refugee crisis, when African refugees, mainly from Sudan and Eritrea, arrived at its shore or rather across the desert from Sinai.

Immigrants from Eritrea in Tel Aviv

Photo: Stefan Boness, http://www.iponphoto.com

This was the first time that an increasing number of non-Jewish people sought refuge in Israel. The Israeli government reaction, perhaps predictably, has been, not unlike that in the UK in relation to contemporary refugee movements, rather hostile, calling the new arrivals ‘infiltrators’ or worse and building fences – metaphorically and literally. At the same time, and in line with happenings elsewhere – one only needs to look at the outpouring of compassion in Germany last summer – a myriad of new civil society organisations has sprung up that focus on refugee issues.

In Israel, these organisations are more often than not funded by Jewish organisations from the diaspora, mainly in the US and some European countries, and this implies that many young, idealistic volunteers form those ‘donor countries’ show up on their doorsteps for an ‘internship’ of some kind, whether there is a need or not. Some of those interns thus work in meaningful positions that require a set of skills, others are simply driven by the wish to do ‘something good’ (often combined with brushing up their CVs). As according to a staff member of an Israeli refugee-NGO, ‘we do not have anything to do for them, really, but also cannot refuse them because we need the donor money’, they end up doing things like taking refugee-babies for a walk, while their mothers are encouraged to do ‘ethnic knit work’ in this freed-up time. Put shortly, often little attention is being paid by such activities to what refugees might want or need, and a lot of well-meaning engagement might in fact turn out to be rather patronising.

One example when those dynamics became apparent was in 2011 when I chatted with a group of Eritrean refugees at the bar of a Tel Aviv nightclub at the launch event for the Refugee Voice newspaper, on the face of it a joint enterprise between refugees and Israeli activists. Very few refugees attended the event, which felt more like a party for the volunteers. Those who did attend stayed among themselves, and when speaking to them told me they preferred to go out to different bars that were not only cheaper but where they could talk to each other quietly. At some point, the newspaper was being presented and the person who gave the speech was an Israeli volunteer. She started by thanking everybody for their input, as ‘I could not have done this without the help of …’ (at which point everybody who contributed an article to the newspaper, refugees and Israelis alike, were mentioned by name). Thus, the newspaper was not presented as a truly joint enterprise in which ‘we’ (Israelis and refugees alike) came together on an equal footing, but as something that was instigated by Israelis concerned with refugee rights quasi on their behalf. In a rather paradoxical way, the claim for universal rights was enacted in this patronizing fashion that indirectly upholds unequal status between refugees and those who advocate on their behalf. This perception was confirmed by some of the Eritreans who did engage with Refugee Voice as an organ to give visibility to their cause. One of its contributors remarked that ‘the newspaper is too timid, it does not really address the important issues we face, just gives some stories of suffering’ – and in doing so enforced what may be called the ‘white-saviour-complex’.

Examples like this raise important questions about the possibility of real solidarity and joint political action that ultimately poses a challenge to exclusions and the denial of fundamental rights – what one could call a politics of resistance. The example above – and a number of others I discuss in my latest publication – do not suggest that civil society engagement is per se futile and patronizing. Some Israeli civil society organisations do indeed use their professional expertise to fight in concrete ways for the rights of refugees and with them – most prominently in the legal field where some small but, given the hostility of an overbearing Israeli state, very important victories have been achieved against a government determined to negate these new refugees any rights.

But overall, a big question mark remains about patterns of engagement and the motivations behind with those who, captured brilliantly in the World Press Photo of the Year 2015 by Warren Richardson at the Hungarian-Serbian border, simply hope for a better life, a life on their terms, a life that is driven by their aspirations. Crossing a border fence is just the starting point here, and much will depend on what type of reception lies beyond it. I have explored these themes in more concrete detail in my latest article that focuses on the specific dynamics of claim-making within the Eritrean refugee community in Tel Aviv, but that holds wider lessons for arriving at new meanings of solidarity and creating a politics of resistance.

The article, Tanja R. Müller, ‘Acts of citizenship as a politics of resistance? Reflections on realizing concrete rights within the Israeli asylum regime’, Citizenship Studies (2016), 20:1, 50-66 is available here (please feel free to email me for a pdf if you cannot access it).

This post was first published on the author’s own blog.

Optimistic rebels vs. the anti-politics machine

By Chris Lyon

The secret has been out the bag for a while now. Time was when the very mention of the words ‘inequality’, ‘distribution’, ‘power’, or, god forbid, ‘state’ in polite development conversation would see canapés dropped in shock and waiters scurrying to fetch the smelling salts. But as a critical mass of wide-scope research, specific on-the-ground knowledge, and social movement and civil society campaigning has grown into an irresistible chorus, the tide seems slowly to be turning. The world of international development, famously labelled ‘the anti-politics machine’ by James Ferguson, is talking about politics, about social justice, state capacity, redistribution.

It was this that I found myself particularly reflecting upon listening to Winnie Byanyima’s invigorating keynote lecture at the launch of the Global Development Institute. The Oxfam International Executive Director – and University of Manchester graduate – ostensibly centred the lecture around an exposition of a vision that Oxfam is branding the Human Economy. However, in truth what stood out was that the terrain covered in outlining this vision fell first and foremost within the ambit of the political.

Reminding the audience that “poverty and extreme inequality are not facts of life coming down from the sky like rain”, but rather the result of political choices and governmental failures, Byanyima unpacked the Human Economy idea through a series of fundamentally political issues: fighting gender injustice; accountable democracy as “the most powerful equalising force ever invented”; the need for governments to rebuff the blackmail tactics of tax-dodging multinationals; the painfully obvious anti-egalitarian effects of privatisation and sky-high fees in education (the air in the University of Manchester lecture theatre felt particularly electric at this point…).

This political focus was evident in the sharpest moment of clarity and insight, which, as often, came in the more spontaneous environment of the post-lecture Q&A session. Responding to a question on what Oxfam can actually achieve, Byanyima answered with arresting frankness that the organisation is undergoing major internal change and will be de-emphasising “being with communities, supporting small communities to find clean water, to build classrooms”. This is a striking comment from the head of a development NGO, given the sector’s characteristic emphasis of its unique selling point of intimate links with real situations and people on the ground. It is worth quoting at length what Byanyima outlined instead:

“We must go out there and tackle power”

 

“We really must go out there and tackle power. Inequality is an issue of power imbalance, and we must recalibrate power. Go to business, go to governments, increase the power of people over them. It’s very political, it’s about campaigning… We are now investing much more in building huge constituencies with workers, students, working to support the growth of social movements against injustice.”

Herein perhaps also lies the answer to another interesting audience question, from a student worried that academic work and a life of ‘just writing articles’ may offer little towards meaningful change in the world. The launch of an institute for the academic study of global development seems a good time to pose this question. But if, as Byanyima argued, questions of politics and power are integral to the reproduction of inequality, injustice, poverty, and to overcoming them, then we need to understand how these dynamics work; how migration, or climate change, or transnational finance are reshaping our societies; how various actors – including universities and NGOs – are connected in often complex webs of power and influence. We need to be able to make compelling arguments about alternative future directions that stand up to detailed scrutiny. This is what rigorous, critical research can offer. There needn’t be a sharp dividing line between the worlds of academic and practitioner/activist, but equally, each can make distinctive contributions that the other can’t.

Byanyima issued a rallying cry for ‘optimistic rebels’ within both activism and academia, and this is a good candidate for a motto as the new GDI gets down to producing knowledge, insight and argument about the deep and complex basis of and alternatives to the inequities all around us. As Winnie Byanyima commented at the outset of her lecture, this is, in fact, what Manchester has long been all about.

Chris Lyon is a PhD candidate at GDI. The working title of his thesis is Exploring a relational conception of social justice: liberals, radicals, and Brazil’s ‘new social contract’

From Manchester to Dhaka. How a master’s led to a work experience with the International Centre for Climate Change and Development (ICCCAD)

By Julia Taub

Many people often wonder what they will do when they finish their studies. I spent most of my master’s year worrying about what would be next. Would I be able to get a job? Would this master’s help? Over the last few months my questions have been (partially) answered, via an internship with the International Centre for Climate Change and Development in Dhaka.

When I first arrived in Manchester I never imagined I would end up working on climate change. That changed when I met my tutor Dr Joanne Jordan. Many of my courses engaged with climate change vulnerability and adaptation, which was Joanne’s area of expertise. I realised that there was more to the climate change sector than just climate science and mitigation, and that adaptation and vulnerability reduction fit well with my development interests.

I decided to focus my dissertation on local-level adaptation, and particularly community-based adaptation (CBA), which turned out to be an emerging area of critical research. So, without fully understanding the specifics of CBA, but keen to learn more, I decided to spend the summer writing my dissertation on its role in reducing climate change vulnerability in Ethiopia. During this time, I spoke to Joanne about potential job opportunities for after completion of my master’s. I was excited to hear about the GDI-ICCCAD 6-month internship programme that she has recently established.

I discovered that ICCCAD will be hosting the 10th CBA conference in April 2016, an international event bringing together researchers, policymakers and practitioners from across the world to share their experiences and the latest developments in CBA. I was keen to get involved in the conference as it would be an excellent opportunity to expand my knowledge and learn from experts in the field.

Gobeshona Conference 2016, image courtesy of ICCCAD

Gobeshona Conference 2016, image courtesy of ICCCAD

Under international climate change expert and pioneer of the 1.5ºC campaign, Dr Saleemul Huq, ICCCAD seemed like an excellent experience for someone trying to break into the climate change and development sector. I spoke with Saleem and he was keen to have me come for an initial period of 6 months and agreed that I could get involved in CBA10.

But I was nervous. I didn’t have a lot of experience, only academic knowledge. I would be working with professionals. However, when I arrived at the start of November, I discovered that there was no need for all those fears. Almost everyone at ICCCAD is a young professional trying to develop the skills and experience needed before moving on to other jobs or to master’s or PhD programmes. ICCCAD is a very supportive training ground!

I took on the role of events coordinator for CBA10. But, since no one here does just one thing, I also jumped at the opportunity to help develop a Monitoring, Evaluation and Learning (MEL) programme. One of MEL’s first projects will be to work in partnership with the International Institute for Environment and Development (IIED) to evaluate the CBA conferences.

ICCAD people

Carbon Pathways Policy Dialogue, image courtesy of ICCCAD

I have now been here for 3 months and have learned how to negotiate with rickshaw pullers and market sellers. I’ve picked up a few key phrases in Bangla (and laugh with others when I don’t say things quite right), and am used to the attention/questions/stares that come with being a foreigner here. I have even been on a local bus! As living and working here is providing much vital in-country cultural experience, I have decided to extend my stay until the end of August. There have been many opportunities for networking at various events and I feel as though the time is going by too quickly.

There is so much more to do and learn and if I leave in right after CBA10, which was the initial plan, I would be missing many opportunities. I am learning loads and am sure that ICCCAD will pave the way into what I hope is a long-term career in the climate change and development sector – a career that I would have never imagined had I not done my master’s at the Global Development Institute. I am sure that my relationship with GDI will not end now that I have completed my master’s. At one event I met someone that works for USAID in Bangladesh who also did his master’s at Manchester and in another month or two, I will be meeting up with Joanne in Dhaka for the second time since I arrived. I am sure that it is only a matter of time before I connect with others who have connections with GDI in one form or another.

 

To learn more about the GDI-ICCCAD internship exchange programme established for the MSc in International Development: Environment, Climate Change and Development, contact Dr Joanne Jordan joanne.jordan@manchester.ac.uk

 

Murder in Egypt – another nail in the coffin of independent fieldwork?

By Tanja Müller

The news from Egypt will send shivers around the spines of all those who try to uphold the value of in-depth, in-country fieldwork as, to use Mark Duffield’s term, an ‘art of being in the world’. On a different level, it is yet another indication of the brutal character of a regime that was created in a military coup but soon enough embraced by a majority of those same ‘Western’ countries keen to lecture the rest of the world endlessly on ‘good governance’.

The news, while not totally unexpected, still came as a shock to many: The body of Giulio Regeni, a 28-old Italian PhD student at the Department of Politics and International Studies (Polis) at the University of Cambridge and visiting scholar at the American University in Cairo (AUC), who had disappeared on 25 January this year, was found. It lay on the side of the Cairo-Alexandria Road on the outskirts of Cairo, marked by multiple stab wounds and cigarette burns according to state prosecutor Ahmed Nagi. Additional reports indicated signs of torture and indications of a slow death, while an official Egyptian spokesperson first suggested Regeni had died in a travel accident!

The night Giulio disappeared, the 25th of January, was the anniversary of the start of the uprising in 2011 against former President Hosni Mubarak, the night that might be considered the start of the ‘Arab Spring’ in Egypt. Then welcomed in the ‘West’, over time it was viewed with more and more suspicion when the version of political Islam propagated by the Muslim Brotherhood under the short-lived presidency of Mohammed Morsi triumphed in elections. When Morsi was ousted in a military coup and many of his followers imprisoned or worse, the initial chill in the relationship with coup-leader and now President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi, was quickly followed by welcoming open arms. After all, Egypt matters, economically to many ‘Western’ countries and companies, and due to its strategic and political role in the Arab world. Thus, David Cameron happily shook hands with al-Sisi, Egypt’s new oppressive strongman, on the steps of Downing Street quite recently, smiles all around. Britain remains the largest foreign investor in Egypt according to the BBC, and while many features of the current government might cause outrage within the human rights lobby, official British politics was content with some mild criticism of the detention of three Al Jazeera journalists, accused by the authorities of supporting terrorism. The fact that hundreds of people disappear on a routine basis for apparently no reason was conveniently ignored – of course not only in Britain but the wider ‘Western’ world. More generally, the way in which al-Sisi and his encourage orchestrate and manipulate the media could be observed up close during an earlier visit by the Egyptian president to Germany, a visit that was equally dominated by economic and other mutual interests.

What will happen now that one of the disappeared was a student in the UK and of Italian nationality? Almost ironically, an Italian business delegation was visiting Egypt when Giulio’s body was found, a delegation with representatives of around 60 companies that had raised high hopes among Egyptian officials for investment in its languishing economy. It cut its visit short and the Egyptian ambassador to Italy was summoned amid a harsh note of protest and a demand for answers by the Italian government. Whether there are any longer-term repercussions for Egypt’s relationship with Europe remains to be seen.

Maybe we will never know what really happened on the night Giulio disappeared – a night full of heavy policy presence in Cairo because of the protest anniversary date, if he was simply at the wrong time in the wrong place, or whether his ‘disappearance’ was part of the government crackdown on those who look behind the scenes and fight for their freedom and rights. Giulio’s research focused on a topic that has become sensitive in the climate of fear that dominates in the country: trade union and labour rights. He might thus have been targeted deliberately like the many Egyptians who fall foul of a detention policy whose main feature is the secrecy around those who simply vanish without traces – without the wider world taking much notice, usually. As a tweet on the University of Cambridge twitter-feed that announced Giulio’s death stated: ‘Welcome to the daily routine of living in the Arab world …”.

Apart from having exposed the nasty nature of the Egyptian regime, the death of a student while conducting fieldwork is the nightmare of any university and of those involved in supervision of projects in distant places. I for once am always relieved when ‘my’ students return safely, as even with all precautions unexpected things do happen – and in many ways form some of the most valuable parts of overseas fieldwork, as they often provide great contributions to our understanding of the wider world. Already, in the increasingly security-obsessed and risk averse environment that characterises many UK universities, it becomes more and more difficult to obtain permission for what were once routine research activities. But especially in times like this, when all over Europe the nastier agendas of the political right bent on exclusion and vilification of ‘the other’ are not only on the rise, but where views formerly regarded as extremist have become mainstream politics, grounded fieldwork that challenges hegemonic narratives is more needed than ever.

See also the coverage in The Mancunian, Academics demand justice after death of Italian student in Egypt.

This article was first posted on Tanja Müller’s Aspiration & Revolution blog.

Gender challenges

The Global Development Institute is hosting an “in conversation” event, marking the launch of Gender Challenges, a three volume compendium of Professor Bina Agarwal’s path-breaking selected papers.

Bina Agarwal, Professor of Development Economics and Environment at the GDI, is internationally acclaimed for her path-breaking writings on agriculture, property rights and the environment. Gender Challenges is a three-volume compendium of her selected essays written over the last three decades. Combining diverse disciplines, methodologies, and cross-country comparisons, the essays both challenge and illuminate standard economic assumptions from a gender perspective. They provide original insights on a wide range of theoretical, empirical, and policy issues of continuing importance in contemporary debates.

Bina Agarwal will be in conversation with Lucia Fry, Head of Policy, ActionAid UK, and Diane Elson, Emeritus Professor, University of Essex. The event will be chaired by Professor Fiona Devine, Head of Alliance Manchester Business School.

In conversation poster final

How can poor people be brought into formalised economies?

kunal-sen-blog

Research Director of the Effective States and Inclusive Development Research Centre Professor Kunal Sen has published a new book: Out of the Shadows? The Informal Sector in Post-Reform India. Here he investigates how the poor can be brought into formalised economies.

Kunal Sen

In recent decades, a number of countries in the developing world have experienced rapid economic growth. Surprisingly though, in the formal sector this growth does not seem to have resulted in high rates of employment.

The global financial crisis is one factor that has led to employment in the formal sector stagnating, or at best, increasing at a slow rate. Simultaneously there has been a rapid rise in the size of the informal sector in many developing countries which has provided residual employment for many retrenched formal sector workers. The informal sector allows for a much needed breathing space for the majority of workers and the importance of this sector as source of jobs and a cushion for adverse economic shocks has been realised by policy-makers.

However at the same time there is concern that, although the informal sector is large and a source of employment, it is also less productive than the formal sector and not contributing much to India’s economic growth.

Policy makers in India face a conundrum. One option is to advocate for a reduced informal economy and relocate as many workers as possible to the formal sector. Another is to promote the well-being of the informal sector and take steps to enhance its vitality and inherent dynamism. read more…

Is there a Brazilian model of development?

By Armando Barrientos and Edmund Amann. Originally published in Policy In Focus, a publication of the UNDP’s International Policy Centre for Inclusive Growth.

As the world begins to wake up to the dire social and economic consequences of rising inequality, we must recognise that it is not an inevitable side-effect of economic growth and development. Many Latin American countries, and Brazil in particular, have demonstrated it is possible to achieve inclusive growth, which has reduced inequality and poverty.

Despite its current difficulties, Brazil offers a striking example of inclusive growth. Inequality has fallen sharply over the past decade and a half, a period which has also seen the country lift an estimated 40 million people out of poverty. Although growth rates have been modest in comparison to China or India, Brazil has implemented a raft of measures to ensure the results of such growth have been shared throughout society. While Brazilians have seen their incomes rise, the poorest have benefited most.

PiF

The growth experienced by Brazil hasn’t simply been attained through the unsustainable exploitation of natural resources. Despite serious lingering problems, deforestation rates in the Amazon have fallen remarkably since 2004. New jobs have been created, child mortality has plummeted, and schooling rates have increased.

So how have these gains been achieved, are they sustainable, what challenges remain, and what can other developing countries learn from Brazil’s experiences? These were the questions asked by a team of researchers from Brazil, Europe and the USA who formed the International Research Initiative on Brazil and Africa (IRIBA). This issue of Policy in Focus looks at the findings and insights they have produced.

The foundations of Brazilian progress can be traced back to the transition from a dictatorship to a democracy in the mid-1980s and the vision for the country which emerged. A firm consensus between citizens and politicians to address the ‘social debt’ created by soaring inequality set the country on a new path. After the economy was stabilised in the mid-1990s, the economic management pursued by successive governments enabled innovative social policies to flourish.

As a more inclusive and prosperous Brazil has developed, the public demand for further progress has also grown. The large protests surrounding the 2014 Football World Cup, worries about an economy mired in recession, and deep concern with serious corruption scandals demonstrate that the Brazilian consensus is under considerable strain. Public demand for better public services and transport infrastructure, less corruption and a more progressive tax system must be addressed by the country’s leaders. While much has improved, Brazil faces pressing challenges. It must ensure that the development gains made over the past decade and a half throughout times of economic growth are not eroded or scaled back throughout the troubling economic times it presently faces. The sustainability of those gains may well be the most important piece of any such Brazilian model of development, yet the jury is still out as to what extent this may be possible.

While the Brazilian experience is the product of a unique set of circumstances, it contains many lessons that should inspire debate and critical appraisal in other developing countries. The world is changing rapidly, and there are more opportunities than ever for genuine cooperation between countries of the Global South with recent and direct experiences of radically reducing poverty. This edition of Policy in Focus is essential reading for anyone grappling with how to reduce poverty and inequality while promoting sustainable and inclusive growth.

Download the full Policy in Focus report.

At what point will we do something about inequality?

by David Hulme, Professor, Global Development Institute

Oxfam’s annual inequality report finds that extreme polarisation – the ownership of global assets by a tiny minority of the world’s population – has increased. Now, only the 62 richest people in the world own the same value of assets as the 3.6 billion people in the bottom half of global incomes – surpassing Oxfam’s original prediction that by 2016, the wealth of the top 1% will equal the wealth of the remaining 99%.
read more…